Since 18 of December 2019 uses Nucleus credentials. Visit our help pages for information on how to Register and Sign-in using Nucleus.
10-15 May 2021
Nice, France
Europe/Vienna timezone
The Conference will be held virtually from 10-15 May 2021

Cross-scale interactions between trapped-electron-mode and electron-temperature-gradient-mode turbulence

13 May 2021, 08:30
Nice, France

Nice, France

Regular Poster Magnetic Fusion Theory and Modelling P5 Posters 5


Shinya Maeyama (Nagoya University)


We have analysed cross-scale interactions between trapped-electron-mode (TEM) and electron-temperature-gradient (ETG) turbulence by means of gyrokinetic simulations. We find that (i) TEM turbulence suppresses ETG turbulence and dominates electron heat transport, and (ii) the suppression of ETG by TEM can ubiquitously happen even when TEM-driven zonal flows are subdominant. Additionally, from the comparison with hydrogen and deuterium plasmas, TEM-stabilized deuterium plasma is affected by ETG, resulting in simultaneous enhancement of TEM and ETG fluctuations. This brings a new perspective on the isotope effects of anomalous electron heat transport via cross-scale interactions between TEM and ETG turbulence.

Cross-scale interactions between electron- and ion-scale fluctuations are one of unresolved issues in turbulent transport. Our previous studies carried out direct numerical simulations of ion-temperature-gradient-mode (ITG) or micro-tearing-mode (MTM) and ETG turbulence, and revealed the mechanism of cross-scale interactions: e.g., ITG turbulent eddies suppress ETG streamers, and ETG turbulence damps short-wavelength zonal flows or localized current sheet of MTM (Maeyama 2017). Besides the theoretical studies, a possible impact of cross-scale interactions in ITER is explored via Tokamak experiments such as Alcator C-Mod, DIII-D (Holland 2017), and JET (Mantica 2020). On the other hand, TEM, which is known as one of important ion-scale instabilities, is not well analyzed in the context of the cross-scale interactions with ETG turbulence. A simulation study for a low magnetic shear plasma reported that TEM-driven zonal flows suppressed ETG turbulence (Asahi 2014). However, it is known that TEM turbulence have a variety of saturation mechanisms depending on plasma parameters where zonal flows are not necessarily dominant. Therefore, one of our key questions is whether TEM coexists with or suppresses ETG, if there is no dominant zonal flow.

To deal with this problem, we set up local flux-tube gyrokinetic simulations resolving electron and ion scales simultaneously. Magnetic field is a circular torus geometry with $q=1.4$, $s=0.8$, $r/R=0.18$. Plasma parameters are $R/L_{Ti}=1$, $R/L_{Te}=9.3$, $R/L_n=3$, $T_e/T_i=3$ and $m_i/m_e=1836$. In these parameters, ITG modes are stable since the ion temperature gradient is low. From the linear analysis, ion-scale fluctuations at $k_y\rho_{ti}<1$ are dominated by TEM, while the electron-scale fluctuations are at $k_y\rho_{ti}>1$ are ETG. Most unstable wavenumbers of these instabilities are roughly separated by the ratio of ion and electron gyro radii.

Figure 1 plots the comparison of electron energy flux spectra. At the early phase of nonlinear simulation ($t=9-12R/v_{ti}$), ETG modes rapidly grow up and saturate. Then ETG driven streamers peaks around $k_y\rho_{ti}=3$ and dominate electron energy flux. Simultaneously, long-wavelength TEM slowly grows up. After the growth of TEM ($t=20-40R/v_{ti}$), TEM turbulence around $k_y\rho_{ti}=0.3$ dominates electron energy flux. One finds that the peak of ETG at electron scale disappears in the presence of TEM. The energy flux level is comparable to that in a low-resolution (single-scale TEM turbulence) simulation plotted in Fig. 1.

Electron energy flux as a function of poloidal wavenumber. Green and blue lines are at early and final saturation phases of multi-scale TEM/ETG turbulence simulation. Red line plots a single-scale TEM turbulence simulation as a reference.

Figure 2 plots the time evolution of electrostatic potential fluctuation of zonal flows ($k_y\rho_{ti} = 0$), TEM ($0 < k_y\rho_{ti} < 1$) and ETG ($1 < k_y\rho_{ti}$). Linear growth of ETG is observed before $t<7R/v_{ti}$. After the saturation of ETG, long wavelength TEM grows with smaller growth rate than the maximum linear growth rate of TEM (plotted by a slope in Fig. 2). The growth of TEM also saturates around $t=16R/v_{ti}$. At the time, both of zonal flows ($k_y\rho_{ti}=0$) and high-wavenumber fluctuations ($1 < k_y\rho_{ti}$) are generated via inverse and forward cascades. It should be noted that the suppression of ETG appears at the same time of TEM growth ($8 < t v_{ti}/R < 14$), but not at the zonal flow generation ($16 < t v_{ti}/R$). Additionally, zonal flow is not the dominant fluctuation of TEM turbulence in this case (e.g., $\langle |\varphi_{k_y}|^2 \rangle =46$ for $k_y\rho_{ti}=0$ and $\langle |\varphi_{k_y}|^2 \rangle = 251$ for $k_y\rho_{ti}=0.3$). This is in contrast with the previous study (Asahi 2014) employing low magnetic shear $s=0.4$ and $T_e/T_i=1$, where ETG is suppressed by TEM-driven strong zonal flows. Our study reveals that strong zonal flows is not necessarily required for the suppression of ETG by TEM. It resembles the suppression of ETG by ITG (Maeyama 2017), where ITG-driven turbulent eddies distort ETG streamers and suppress them.

Time evolution of electrostatic potential fluctuations of zonal flow (red), TEM (green), and ETG (blue) in multi-scale TEM/ETG turbulence. Maximum linear growth rate of ETG and TEM are also plotted by solid slopes as a reference.

We have also carried out a multi-scale TEM/ETG turbulence simulation for the deuterium plasma ($m_i/m_e=3672$), where linear growth rates of TEM are reduced by the collisional isotope effect (Nakata 2017). Simultaneous enhancement of TEM and ETG fluctuations with stronger electron heat transport than that in the ion-scale TEM turbulence simulation is observed, suggesting cross-scale interactions of TEM and ETG turbulence.

Our study expands the understanding of cross-scale interactions between ion- and electron-scale turbulence. It is found that ETG is suppressed by TEM turbulence even when zonal flows are subdominant. Comparison with hydrogen and deuterium plasmas brings a new insight into isotope effects via cross-scale interactions. Experimental measurement of electron-scale fluctuations will be desired future in context of isotope effects.


(Maeyama 2017) S. Maeyama et al., Nucl. Fusion 57 (2017) 066036; Phys. Rev. Lett. 119 (2017) 195002.
(Holland 2017) C. Holland et al., Nucl. Fusion 57 (2017) 066043.
(Mantica 2020) P. Mantica et al., Plasma Phys. Control. Fusion 62 (2020) 014021.
(Asahi 2014) Y. Asahi et al., Phys. Plasmas 21 (2014) 052306.
(Nakata 2017) M. Nakata et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 118 (2017) 165002.

Affiliation Department of Physics, Nagoya University
Country or International Organization Japan

Primary author

Shinya Maeyama (Nagoya University)


Tomo-Hiko Watanabe (National Institute for Fusion Science)

Presentation Materials

There are no materials yet.